Reviews that Are 100% Objective

Friday, January 03, 2014 - 02:19 PM

Video Game Show (Rockstar Games)

Video game criticism is a weird beast. 

Partly because there’s still an argument surrounding whether or not Video Games are Art, the criticism of games isn’t particularly great. It’s sort of like film criticism before film criticism became a truly great medium of its own. A lot of buyer’s guide-style reviews, many of which are suspiciously puffy.

Some video game critics do what critics ought to, which is to engage with the ideas that animate a work, investigate what the work is trying to do, and to imagine a better, higher version of an art form and agitate for it.*

In general though, the larger audience for video games just wants to know if a game is good or not, and gets angry when a writer intimates that they’d like to engage with the work beyond pointing out that the graphics are pretty, there’s a lot of cool guns, and the cut-scenes are boring.

Enter Objective Game Reviews. A new site that claims to be catering to that audience, the audience that just wants a thumbs up or a thumbs down, without a bunch of opinion and subjectivity.

It’s a one note joke, but pulled off pretty well. Here’s the entirety of their review of Natural Selection 2:

Natural Selection 2 is a multiplayer game that is a mixed first person shooter and strategy game. Aliens and marines fight over various locations in a first person shooter, while a commander on each team researches upgrades, builds buildings, and issues orders. Aliens can chuckle at their enemies while marines can dispense a variety of taunts, including one that goes “now there’s something you don’t see every day… thank God.” 

It will be interesting to see how far this goes. It’s pulled off straight-facedly enough that you can almost imagine an audience going for it.


*I really like Leigh Alexander's work a lot.  Alex and I are both into Jamin Brophy-Warren. Also, Anita Sarkeesian, who got death threats (death threats!) in response to Feminist Frequency, her series about how women are represented in various media, including video games.


More in:

Comments [2]

Nick Nobel

Reminds me of Dennis Farrell's "If Films Were Reviewed Like Video Games" on Something Awful, which satirically critiques World War Z with the similar rote banality that most video game reviews contain.

Jan. 03 2014 04:22 PM
Objective Game Reviews

Hi PJ. We're glad you like our site! One small point, though. You quote what you say is "the entirety of [our] review of Natural Selection 2," but that's actually just the section before the jump, on our homepage. You can click the "Continue Reading" button to see the rest of the review, or simply visit this link:

Thanks for linking to us!

Jan. 03 2014 02:40 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Supported by

Embed the TLDR podcast player

TLDR is a short podcast and blog about the internet by Meredith Haggerty. You can subscribe to the TLDR podcast here. You can follow our blog here. I tweet @manymanywords and @tldr.

Subscribe to Podcast iTunes RSS